Regarding Intelligence of Ashkenazi Jews
24 Aug 2005
On The Evolution Of Ashkenazi Jewish Intelligence
Ashkenazi Jews pose two mysteries for biological science. First, why do they have so many genetic diseases that fall into just a few categories of metabolic function such as the sphingolipd storage diseases Tay-Sachs, Gaucher, Niemann-Pick, and mucolipidosis type IV? The rates of such diseases are so high that their incidence must be the result of either a recent genetic bottleneck where the Ashkenazi population was very small or natural selective pressures aimed at some other phenotype(s) selected for these genotypes due to advantages that those genotypes offer for other functionality. The second mystery is why are Jews so smart? Granted, a lot of Jews want to argue that they are just studious due to their culture. Also, lots of ideologues - particularly on the political Left - stand ready to attack anyone who argues that ethnic and racial groups differ in average intelligence. But the higher average level of Ashkenazi Jewish intelligence is so glaringly obvious that I figure anyone who tries to argue otherwise is either engaged in intellectual con artistry or is ignorant or foolish. So again, why are Jews so smart?
Well, three researchers at the University of Utah, anthropologist Henry Harpending, Gregory Cochran (a Ph.D. physicist turned genetic theorist), and Jason Hardy put forth a hypothesis that seeks to explain both mysteries simultaneously. Nicholas Wade of the New York Times has written one of the two news stories about it to date. The proposed hypothesis holds that Jews developed their genetic diseases as a side effect of strong selective pressures for higher intelligence during the Middle Ages as they were forced to work mainly in occupations that required greater cognitive ability.
....
Read the futurepundit entry in it's entirety. Links to other news articles are available through the extropy thread created on this topic.
Other Source(s):
http://bbs.extropy.o...;threadid=60936
http://www.economist...tory_id=4032638
ilia
25 Aug 2005
why are Jews so smart?
The proposed hypothesis holds that Jews developed their genetic diseases as a side effect of strong selective pressures for higher intelligence during the Middle Ages as they were forced to work mainly in occupations that required greater cognitive ability.
Wrong premise and wrong theory.
Of course, a hostile environment may promote intelligence, but not due to natural selection, but rather because of social reasons (the immediate need to survive). Evidence: here in Israel live the same Ashkenazi Jews, but the intelligence gene must have been knocked out in a large part of the population. I love the folk-tale about Schildburgers (a certain German community) who were famous for their intelligence when they lived in foreign countries, but when they gathered together they became plain stupid
boogaboo
15 Sep 2005
Most Israeli jews are Spharadim, not Ashkenazim.
Most (almost all) of US jews are Ashkenazim.
Perhaps we mix too much here in Israel, or am I just too smart?
Send money to a poor Ashkenazi
