• Log in with Facebook Log in with Twitter Log In with Google      Sign In    
  • Create Account
  LongeCity
              Advocacy & Research for Unlimited Lifespans

Photo
- - - - -

Krill oil or fish oil?

krill oil fish oil brain health supplement

  • Please log in to reply
5 replies to this topic

#1 Ace Silver

  • Guest
  • 20 posts
  • 1
  • Location:Ohio
  • NO

Posted 10 July 2014 - 11:48 PM


I'm interesting in knowing the real difference between fish oil and krill oil are, would enjoy links to sources of information found, if not  then that's fine, all information regarding this topic is welcomed. Also I would like to know which oil everyone is taking (including the amount dosed) and if you have noticed any sort of positive benefit from taking it daily as compared to a placebo effect. Let's start a conversation.  :-D

Side note: I have diagnosed adult-ADHD and I have heard supplementation of krill oil can improve symptoms of ADHD. True or false?



#2 holdout

  • Guest
  • 37 posts
  • 19
  • Location:Canada

Posted 11 July 2014 - 04:29 AM

Fish oil is a broad term and is not the same as krill oil.  It could mean cod liver oil and other things.  I think you're thinking of Omega-3 fatty acid supplements (which are usually derived from fish) VS. Omega-3 fatty acid supplements derived from krill.  The ones from krill are more absorbable/bioavailable/potent than the ones from fish.  That's the only real difference.  On average instead of taking 3 large softgels of Omega-3 (which is from fish) you could take just 1 medium softgel of krill-derived Omega-3 which is a lesser dose, but the bioavailability to your body will be equivalent just the same.

 

It might help for ADHD for some people but I wouldn't expect the results to be so dramatic unless you combine it with other dietary supplements.  For ADHD I advocate trying a Dr. Marty Hinz-based regimen:

 

Take once daily with a meal:

- 500 mg tryptophan

- 500 mg tyrosine

- 100 mg 5-HTP

- 100 mg L-DOPA

- 200 mg SAMe


  • Dangerous, Irresponsible x 4

sponsored ad

  • Advert
Click HERE to rent this advertising spot for SUPPLEMENTS (in thread) to support LongeCity (this will replace the google ad above).

#3 holdout

  • Guest
  • 37 posts
  • 19
  • Location:Canada

Posted 12 July 2014 - 05:29 AM

Fish oil is a broad term and is not the same as krill oil.  It could mean cod liver oil and other things.  I think you're thinking of Omega-3 fatty acid supplements (which are usually derived from fish) VS. Omega-3 fatty acid supplements derived from krill.  The ones from krill are more absorbable/bioavailable/potent than the ones from fish.  That's the only real difference.  On average instead of taking 3 large softgels of Omega-3 (which is from fish) you could take just 1 medium softgel of krill-derived Omega-3 which is a lesser dose, but the bioavailability to your body will be equivalent just the same.

 

It might help for ADHD for some people but I wouldn't expect the results to be so dramatic unless you combine it with other dietary supplements.  For ADHD I advocate trying a Dr. Marty Hinz-based regimen:

 

Take once daily with a meal:

- 500 mg tryptophan

- 500 mg tyrosine

- 100 mg 5-HTP

- 100 mg L-DOPA

- 200 mg SAMe

 

My regimen is FAAAR from dangerous/irresponsible.  I've even tried it myself personally several times.  I would never recommend something that could endanger one's health.  Here is the research it's based on: http://www.neuroscie...z-and-stein.htm  They have had success in treating all kinds of maladies/ailments by providing a unique formulation of those 5 factors concomitantly as a daily regimen for people.  Please consider removing the dangerous/irresponsible flag on my post above. :)


Edited by holdout, 12 July 2014 - 05:31 AM.


#4 Zaul

  • Guest
  • 120 posts
  • 16
  • Location:unknown

Posted 12 July 2014 - 08:39 AM

Don't waste money on fish oils (or any oil for that matter). Omega 3 fatty acids are one the biggest fad in the diet/supplement field.

 

 


Edited by Nigeria Custom Officer, 12 July 2014 - 08:39 AM.

  • Needs references x 1
  • Disagree x 1

#5 serp777

  • Guest
  • 622 posts
  • 11
  • Location:who cares

Posted 12 July 2014 - 06:21 PM

 

Fish oil is a broad term and is not the same as krill oil.  It could mean cod liver oil and other things.  I think you're thinking of Omega-3 fatty acid supplements (which are usually derived from fish) VS. Omega-3 fatty acid supplements derived from krill.  The ones from krill are more absorbable/bioavailable/potent than the ones from fish.  That's the only real difference.  On average instead of taking 3 large softgels of Omega-3 (which is from fish) you could take just 1 medium softgel of krill-derived Omega-3 which is a lesser dose, but the bioavailability to your body will be equivalent just the same.

 

It might help for ADHD for some people but I wouldn't expect the results to be so dramatic unless you combine it with other dietary supplements.  For ADHD I advocate trying a Dr. Marty Hinz-based regimen:

 

Take once daily with a meal:

- 500 mg tryptophan

- 500 mg tyrosine

- 100 mg 5-HTP

- 100 mg L-DOPA

- 200 mg SAMe

 

My regimen is FAAAR from dangerous/irresponsible.  I've even tried it myself personally several times.  I would never recommend something that could endanger one's health.  Here is the research it's based on: http://www.neuroscie...z-and-stein.htm  They have had success in treating all kinds of maladies/ailments by providing a unique formulation of those 5 factors concomitantly as a daily regimen for people.  Please consider removing the dangerous/irresponsible flag on my post above. :)

 

Stacking seratonin and dopamine precursors sounds pretty irresponsible to me. Why would you need 5htp and tryptophan? Why would seratonin help someone with add? I understand the dopamine logic for that, but there are far better options for nootropics than this, like magnesium for example. 



sponsored ad

  • Advert
Click HERE to rent this advertising spot for SUPPLEMENTS (in thread) to support LongeCity (this will replace the google ad above).

#6 holdout

  • Guest
  • 37 posts
  • 19
  • Location:Canada

Posted 14 July 2014 - 09:20 PM

 

 

Fish oil is a broad term and is not the same as krill oil.  It could mean cod liver oil and other things.  I think you're thinking of Omega-3 fatty acid supplements (which are usually derived from fish) VS. Omega-3 fatty acid supplements derived from krill.  The ones from krill are more absorbable/bioavailable/potent than the ones from fish.  That's the only real difference.  On average instead of taking 3 large softgels of Omega-3 (which is from fish) you could take just 1 medium softgel of krill-derived Omega-3 which is a lesser dose, but the bioavailability to your body will be equivalent just the same.

 

It might help for ADHD for some people but I wouldn't expect the results to be so dramatic unless you combine it with other dietary supplements.  For ADHD I advocate trying a Dr. Marty Hinz-based regimen:

 

Take once daily with a meal:

- 500 mg tryptophan

- 500 mg tyrosine

- 100 mg 5-HTP

- 100 mg L-DOPA

- 200 mg SAMe

 

My regimen is FAAAR from dangerous/irresponsible.  I've even tried it myself personally several times.  I would never recommend something that could endanger one's health.  Here is the research it's based on: http://www.neuroscie...z-and-stein.htm  They have had success in treating all kinds of maladies/ailments by providing a unique formulation of those 5 factors concomitantly as a daily regimen for people.  Please consider removing the dangerous/irresponsible flag on my post above. :)

 

Stacking seratonin and dopamine precursors sounds pretty irresponsible to me. Why would you need 5htp and tryptophan? Why would seratonin help someone with add? I understand the dopamine logic for that, but there are far better options for nootropics than this, like magnesium for example. 

 

It's not at all irresponsible.  This is why I have provided a link to all the research but I find that you're still asking questions that are answered on the website I have provided.  Here is a concrete example of a research study dedicated to ADHD whereby 85 human subjects were provided a regimen similar to the one I have provided as stated in my original post; a Dr. Marty Hinz-based regimen: http://www.ncbi.nlm....les/PMC3035600/

 

The research does not prove how it works, but for someone like me it's rather obvious: since dopaminergic neurons can affect serotonergic neurons and vice versa, the strategy here is to strengthen the innate neuronal physiology for cognition by exploiting neuroplasticity, so that one can stay focussed rather than having random thoughts cause their cognition to stray from the current thought.  Supplementing concomitantly in this way, elevates innate levels of serotonin & dopamine neurotransmitters for a temporary boost in neuronal firing while alleviating ADHD symptoms via a more solid cognition.  Then, as signals pass through neuronal bundles, neuroplasticity reinforces these pathways by having dendrites reach out to other neurons and improve the function of each bundle, so that chronically the physiology of the brain is bolder in terms of establishing a cohesive mindset that can stay focussed.  According to Hinz's research, if a person supplements just one of the amino acids or precursors I have specified, they will cause a reduction in neurotransmitter levels of the other (dopamine VS. serotonin), so not taking all of those concomitantly with a methyl donor would be detrimental for one's prognosis of their malady.

 

Please see Figure 1: http://www.neuroscie..._hypothesis.pdf


Edited by holdout, 14 July 2014 - 09:24 PM.






Also tagged with one or more of these keywords: krill oil, fish oil, brain health, supplement

1 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users