5 replies to this topic

[Michael Lustgarten]

https://www.youtube....h?v=cOg91UU6NNY

Attached Files

•  rdw.png   480.9KB   0 downloads

[albedo]

Great Michael. Maybe I overlooked, but shouldn't it be 11.4 - 11.9 (vs your 12.6) in your reproduced chart for the 1-5 and 5-25 percentiles in Tonelli 2019?

 

 Screenshot 2024-02-17 135322.png   674.55KB   0 downloads

[albedo]

Great Michael. Maybe I overlooked, but shouldn't it be 11.4 - 11.9 (vs your 12.6) in your reproduced chart for the 1-5 and 5-25 percentiles in Tonelli 2019?

 

 Screenshot 2024-02-17 135322.png   674.55KB   0 downloads

[Michael Lustgarten]

Thanks Albedo for your critical eye!

In Table 1 from that paper, they listed the minimum values for each percentile, and 12.6 is the beginning of the 25-50% percentile. That means that the optimal range is from the minimum value in percentile 1 (11.4) to just before the 25th percentile (12.59)...

Edited by Michael Lustgarten, 17 February 2024 - 01:58 PM.

[albedo]

Of course .. bad me! Got it

[Michael Lustgarten]

No worries, albedo, you almost got me! Initially, I thought I made a mistake, but when I took another look at the paper, not this time  

Ha, eventually someone will get me, which is ok, everyone misspeaks/makes mistakes eventually...