Whenever I try to supplement with Vitamin D I am left with serious constipation and bloating that abate two days after taking the substance. Its so bad that I don't take it even though my levels were last tested around 30 ng. I havn't really been able to find much info about it, I was thinking that perhaps it is increasing production of catecholamines which is messing with motility. Normally I have some problems in that dept but nothing too bad. I find that magnesium doesn't really help. Any ideas?

Vitamin D and Constipation
#1
Posted 06 April 2010 - 03:35 PM
Whenever I try to supplement with Vitamin D I am left with serious constipation and bloating that abate two days after taking the substance. Its so bad that I don't take it even though my levels were last tested around 30 ng. I havn't really been able to find much info about it, I was thinking that perhaps it is increasing production of catecholamines which is messing with motility. Normally I have some problems in that dept but nothing too bad. I find that magnesium doesn't really help. Any ideas?
#2
Posted 06 April 2010 - 04:59 PM
#3
Posted 06 April 2010 - 05:40 PM
Whenever I try to supplement with Vitamin D I am left with serious constipation and bloating that abate two days after taking the substance. Its so bad that I don't take it even though my levels were last tested around 30 ng. I havn't really been able to find much info about it, I was thinking that perhaps it is increasing production of catecholamines which is messing with motility. Normally I have some problems in that dept but nothing too bad. I find that magnesium doesn't really help. Any ideas?
Are you supplementing with too much calcium?
#4
Posted 08 April 2010 - 06:49 AM
Try a different brand. Make sure it is an oil based gel capsule (or liquid) of Vitamin D3.Any ideas?
If that fails, go read a book in the sun

#5
Posted 09 April 2010 - 01:46 AM
#6
Posted 09 April 2010 - 10:08 AM
It took me a long time to figure out why. What I noticed, whilst maintaining (what many here would call) "ideal" Vitamin D blood levels, that eating any source of calcium would sooner or later cause great constipation. It was extremely uncomfortable! Supplementing with vitamin D caused my digestive track to become very sensitive to any calcium containing foods.
I'm beginning to realise there is more to this hormone than many realise.
Maybe one way to get around this effect is one large dose of vitamin d3 each month, instead of spread out each day. Also, it may be wise to supplement with Vitamin K2 (MK4 or MK7) and Magnesium (preferably in glycinate form).
#7
Posted 09 April 2010 - 07:37 PM
Calcium on its own can cause constipation as well, and it seems vitamin D can complicate this further:Supplementing with vitamin D caused my digestive track to become very sensitive to any calcium containing foods.
If you take tablets with vitamin D in them, the level of calcium in your blood may get too high. Doctors call this hypercalcaemia. It can be dangerous. But this is more likely to happen if you take a type of vitamin D called calcitriol.
If you already have side effects from low doses, this may not be wise, and (I would guess) wouldn't be as effective in raising your levels if only taken once a month.Maybe one way to get around this effect is one large dose of vitamin d3 each month, instead of spread out each day.
Here's a solution which seemed to help some people with this problem:
It's probably MORE likely that you are constipated because of Magnesium Deficiency. And as it takes magnesium to convert Vitamin D into the active form, you may just be using up more magnesium than usual and causing constipation.
Don't stop the D, just take a magnesium supplement (anything but magnsium oxide) and increase the magnesium slowly until you have between 1 to 3 soft bowel movements a day. If you get loose stools, then just decrease the dosage a little, but don't STOP taking the magnesium.
Kerri Knox, RN
Functional Medicine Practitioner
http://www.easy-immune-health.com
I would normally recommend magnesium glycinate, malate, or taurate to avoid the possibility of loose stool. But if those don't help, those effects of magnesium citrate may actually help?
#8
Posted 11 April 2010 - 03:01 AM
Edited by simon341, 11 April 2010 - 03:04 AM.
#9
Posted 11 April 2010 - 03:31 AM
I was taking the Carlson Gel Cap @ 2000 IU then swithced to the D Drops because I heard they might help. I tried taking magnesium concurrently and it did nothing. In fact, I even stopped the magnesium recently and have been more regular than ever! I think I might ask my doctor to double check if there might be a serious problem with the metabolism of D3 but I suppose it might just be making me hypersensitive. Dehbleh what was your eventual solution? I'm not deficient right now @ 30, but would like to get to between 45 and 60. I don't supplement with calcium, and like I said magnesium didn't help. Does anyone here second the suggestion of K2, I thought that might help? Vitamin C also seems to be helping.
K2 is a great supplement to take in its own right. It helps *reverse* arterial calcification.
Study Shows Vitamin K2 Plays Significant Role in Cardiovascular Health
2007-04-02 - VitaK, Maastricht University
Research Published in Blood Journal Leads to New Human Test for Cardiovascular Disease Risk to Be Presented at American Heart Association Conference ATVB Conference
April 19-21 2007
WASHINGTON -- April 2, 2007 -- A new study published in the April 1, 2007 (volume 109, number 7) issue of Blood, the official journal of the American Society of Hematology, suggests that vitamin K2 provides significant benefits for promoting cardiovascular health. The study shows for the first time that a high intake of vitamin K significantly reverses arterial calcification induced with anti-coagulant medication use.
The animal study, conducted by the Cardiovascular Research Institute (CARIM) and VitaK, Maastricht University, The Netherlands, found that high dose vitamin K not only blocked new arterial calcium buildup, but also reduced existing levels by over 37 percent, within only 6 weeks. The most potent inhibitor of vascular calcification known is matrix GLA protein (MGP), a vitamin K-dependent protein – meaning vitamin K is required to activate this important protein. In humans, oral anticoagulants that interfere with vitamin K (warfarins) block MGP function and induce calcification. Also, inactive MGP levels in blood are an indicator of cardiovascular disease, and a new test has been developed to measure these levels. This new test will be presented at the American Heart Association’s 2007 Annual Conference on Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology to be held April 19-21 at the Palmer House Hilton, Chicago, Illinois.
Calcium buildup in arteries is an early warning sign of increased risk on coronary heart disease in humans. People with higher arterial calcium levels are more likely to develop arteriolosclerosis, stroke and other heart ailments later in life than those with normal levels. Researchers also note as evidence the increased risk of calcium in blood vessels (arterial calcification) associated with cardiovascular disease in people with vitamin K-poor diets.
“The medical community now recognizes that vitamin K-dependent MGP plays an essential role in promoting cardiovascular health,” said lead researcher Leon Schurgers. “Our study shows that in an animal model vitamin K can actually regress preformed calcifications. The health implications for humans are significant, and we have previously published research showing that the highest vitamin K2 intake from dietary sources has been linked to significant reductions in vascular calcification compared to those with the lowest K2 intake.”
In a recent 10-year study of 4,800 elderly people published in the Journal of Nutrition, high vitamin K2 intake was linked to lower coronary heart disease, less aortic calcification and lower all cause mortality. “Research is showing much promise associated with vitamin K intake and heart health, and people should be encouraged to discuss vitamin K use with their physician,” added Dr. Schurgers.
------------------------------------
Another link with 4 studies referenced:
http://www.vitak.com...k1.pdf?id=75445
#10
Posted 11 April 2010 - 03:38 AM
I was taking the Carlson Gel Cap @ 2000 IU then swithced to the D Drops because I heard they might help. I tried taking magnesium concurrently and it did nothing. In fact, I even stopped the magnesium recently and have been more regular than ever! I think I might ask my doctor to double check if there might be a serious problem with the metabolism of D3 but I suppose it might just be making me hypersensitive. Dehbleh what was your eventual solution? I'm not deficient right now @ 30, but would like to get to between 45 and 60. I don't supplement with calcium, and like I said magnesium didn't help. Does anyone here second the suggestion of K2, I thought that might help? Vitamin C also seems to be helping.
K2 is a great supplement to take in its own right. It helps *reverse* arterial calcification.
Study Shows Vitamin K2 Plays Significant Role in Cardiovascular Health
2007-04-02 - VitaK, Maastricht University
Research Published in Blood Journal Leads to New Human Test for Cardiovascular Disease Risk to Be Presented at American Heart Association Conference ATVB Conference
April 19-21 2007
WASHINGTON -- April 2, 2007 -- A new study published in the April 1, 2007 (volume 109, number 7) issue of Blood, the official journal of the American Society of Hematology, suggests that vitamin K2 provides significant benefits for promoting cardiovascular health. The study shows for the first time that a high intake of vitamin K significantly reverses arterial calcification induced with anti-coagulant medication use.
The animal study, conducted by the Cardiovascular Research Institute (CARIM) and VitaK, Maastricht University, The Netherlands, found that high dose vitamin K not only blocked new arterial calcium buildup, but also reduced existing levels by over 37 percent, within only 6 weeks. The most potent inhibitor of vascular calcification known is matrix GLA protein (MGP), a vitamin K-dependent protein – meaning vitamin K is required to activate this important protein. In humans, oral anticoagulants that interfere with vitamin K (warfarins) block MGP function and induce calcification. Also, inactive MGP levels in blood are an indicator of cardiovascular disease, and a new test has been developed to measure these levels. This new test will be presented at the American Heart Association’s 2007 Annual Conference on Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis, and Vascular Biology to be held April 19-21 at the Palmer House Hilton, Chicago, Illinois.
Calcium buildup in arteries is an early warning sign of increased risk on coronary heart disease in humans. People with higher arterial calcium levels are more likely to develop arteriolosclerosis, stroke and other heart ailments later in life than those with normal levels. Researchers also note as evidence the increased risk of calcium in blood vessels (arterial calcification) associated with cardiovascular disease in people with vitamin K-poor diets.
“The medical community now recognizes that vitamin K-dependent MGP plays an essential role in promoting cardiovascular health,” said lead researcher Leon Schurgers. “Our study shows that in an animal model vitamin K can actually regress preformed calcifications. The health implications for humans are significant, and we have previously published research showing that the highest vitamin K2 intake from dietary sources has been linked to significant reductions in vascular calcification compared to those with the lowest K2 intake.”
In a recent 10-year study of 4,800 elderly people published in the Journal of Nutrition, high vitamin K2 intake was linked to lower coronary heart disease, less aortic calcification and lower all cause mortality. “Research is showing much promise associated with vitamin K intake and heart health, and people should be encouraged to discuss vitamin K use with their physician,” added Dr. Schurgers.
------------------------------------
Another link with 4 studies referenced:
http://www.vitak.com...k1.pdf?id=75445
Which K2 product do you take?
#11
Posted 11 April 2010 - 03:43 AM
Which K2 product do you take?
Jarrow MK-7
http://www.jarrow.co....php?prodid=241
From my reading, there is more research to support MK-7 than MK-4 especially for cardiovascular benefits (but this is contested here).
#12
Posted 11 April 2010 - 03:46 AM
I was taking the Carlson Gel Cap @ 2000 IU then switched to the D Drops because I heard they might help. I tried taking magnesium concurrently and it did nothing. In fact, I even stopped the magnesium recently and have been more regular than ever! I think I might ask my doctor to double check if there might be a serious problem with the metabolism of D3 but I suppose it might just be making me hypersensitive. Dehbleh what was your eventual solution? I'm not deficient right now @ 30, but would like to get to between 45 and 60. I don't supplement with calcium, and like I said magnesium didn't help. Does anyone here second the suggestion of K2, I thought that might help? Vitamin C also seems to be helping.
I believe the constipation issues only happened to me when taking Vitamin D3. Once off weekly doses didn't correct the problem either. Avoiding calcium (temporarily) and adding Magnesium Glycinate + Vitamin K2 corrected the problem within 3 days. For this reason I believe taking Vitamin D3 by itself is a flawed approach.
You could try a once off mega-dose instead of daily dosing but be extremely careful! I was taking roughly 50,000 ui throughout the week, once I switched this to a single weekly dose my levels rose from 55 to -> 88 within 4 months. To my surprise it was much more potent.
These days I don't supplement Vitamin D3 much as it really upsets my gut (would you believe it?). I can't tolerate fish oil for the same reason. Intense nausea, burning pain and reflux occur within 5 minutes of dosing. Main source these days is lots of sun and occasional 50,000 ui mega dose when I feel a cold coming on (works great btw). No more constipation.
This hormone has had a tremendous amount of press coverage within the supplement community but I think everyone's forgetting the overall picture a bit. There are other pieces to the puzzle and I think we'll be hearing a lot more about it over the coming months, even years.
Stephen from Whole Health Source posted something recently.
http://wholehealthso...metabolism.html
Edited by dehbleh, 11 April 2010 - 03:47 AM.
#13
Posted 11 April 2010 - 05:02 AM
I get something similar. My doctor put my on 50,000IU/day (HUGE dose) to correct levels of 17ng/mL, and within a week I was getting a stabbing pain in my stomach starting several hours after my dose. Made it very difficult to eat. I've titrated down to 10,000/day now, and only get a few twinges if I have a heavy meal later in the day.These days I don't supplement Vitamin D3 much as it really upsets my gut (would you believe it?).
Good link. Also highlights the importance of magnesium for proper Vit D metabolism, and a few other cofactors.Stephen from Whole Health Source posted something recently.
http://wholehealthso...metabolism.html
1 user(s) are reading this topic
0 members, 1 guests, 0 anonymous users