He is a bit like the Don Quixote from the novel (he does look a bit like it, doesn't he). His fight against aging is lost, not scientifically, but in the hearts..
That's what I note after watching this debate.
Because aging is, for the people, a very emotional problem, not a scientific one. Have you noticed the first remark of DrBlakemore: I am not a specialist in aging but I will debate with you... even with the audience, supposed to be 'scientifically-minded' : the questions of everyone point out that they don't know a lot about it. But everyone got his idea about it!
Aging is so anchored inside the mind of the people, the fact that we can't (and shouldn't) change our nature, etc.
This is a pessimistic remark... but we aren't completely lost! Because the secret magic word is: Revujenation medicine! Not anti-aging medicine.
The New Organ prize is the solution, and a fantastic idea. I think the name 'Methuselah Fundation' shouldn't be associated aside this project. Have you noticed the remark by DrBlakemore: 'You're speaking about health but your fundation's name is Methuselah, isn't it?' (like it was some sin).
Rejuvenation is good.
I don't think this type of debate that I've just watched has an utility for the public.
Edited by Pour_la_Science, 31 July 2012 - 07:04 AM.