• Log in with Facebook Log in with Twitter Log In with Google      Sign In    
  • Create Account
  LongeCity
              Advocacy & Research for Unlimited Lifespans

Photo
- - - - -

[FightAging] Possibly Overly Focused on Telomeres


  • Please log in to reply
4 replies to this topic

#1 reason

  • Guardian Reason
  • 1,101 posts
  • 251
  • Location:US

Posted 24 June 2013 - 11:07 AM


A simplistic view of telomere length seems to be percolating into the public view of aging, judging by some of the recent discussions on the topic I've encountered. The average disinterested fellow in the street might now have the idea that telomeres somehow get shorter and in doing so cause aging. I expect that this mistaken echo from the halls of science will be reinforced as new telomere assessment services flush with venture funding continue to publicize themselves via the mainstream media.

In fact, telomere length is fairly dynamic and varied, and a lot of uncertain remains in its role in aging. In immune cells the average telomere length seems to correlate well with general health on a statistical basis across a population, being on average shorter in ill people. There are ways to measure telomere length in some animal species that do a good job of predicting likely life expectancy. Delivering additional telomerase, the enzyme that lengthens telomeres, to mice increases their life span. Nonetheless, it's very much up in the air as to whether reduced telomere length is a cause of aging versus a secondary effect of other processes that nonetheless causes some harm of its own, versus just being a marker of the progression of degenerative aging. That telomerase therapy might be extending life through some unrelated function of telomerase, perhaps one involving reducing the level of mitochondrial damage in cells.

Of the mechanisms of aging cataloged in the SENS rejuvenation research proposals, only cancer prevention involves telomeres. All of the other ways in which your metabolism becomes damaged over time have nothing much to do with telomere length. But here is a recent article on science and longevity that focuses on telomeres:

[Telomeres are] tiny structures at the ends of your chromosomes that keep them from fraying and losing crucial bits of genetic information. What interests researchers who study aging is that when cells divide, their telomeres get shorter. Once they get too short, cells stops dividing and may die. Played out across the whole body, there's mounting evidence that shorter telomeres translate into increased susceptibility to diseases and the gradual wearing out of tissues that is the hallmark of old age.

It's tempting to think of our telomeres as the cellular equivalents of the grim reaper's hourglass, counting out our predetermined life spans. But the hourglass can get periodic refills - thanks to an enzyme called telomerase, which acts to build telomeres back up. And the rise of telomere testing for consumers is also pegged to evidence that telomere length is not just an inherited inevitability but may be influenced by factors such as stress, exercise and nutrition. The thinking is, if you can regularly monitor your telomere length, you'll be more apt to do the right things to slow the rate at which they're burning away.

Despite media reports, telomeres do not actually tell you how long you are going to live. That's because there's a huge variation between individuals. A teenager can have shorter telomeres than a 70-year-old, yet that teenager is far more likely to still be around in 20 years. The correlation between telomere length and lifespan is something that emerges when larger numbers of individuals are analyzed as a group.

With the field still trying to figure out exactly how telomeres relate to aging and health, some researchers express strong reservations about telomere testing for health assessment - and taking tests at face value. "It's easy to get correlations in aging, because many, many things are affected as you get older," says David Harrison, a gerontologist at the Jackson Laboratory in Bar Harbor, Me. While he doesn't rule out that telomeres play a role in aging, he is not persuaded that their role is clear or that telomere testing is meaningful. And he is wary, he says, when researchers in the field have a commercial interest in the testing technology.

Link: http://www.theglobea...54905/?page=all


<br> <br>View the full article
  • like x 1

#2 niner

  • Guest
  • 16,276 posts
  • 1,999
  • Location:Philadelphia

Posted 25 June 2013 - 02:25 AM

Thanks for another great post, Reason. Telomeres are a good example of the degree to which humans are enthralled by narrative. The telomere "story" resonates well, and seems to have taken hold in the general population. Witness the squalid case of "Product B". I suspect telomeres are a minor player in aging, but they are a lever that we can pull on, however small it may be. Testing is getting more sophisticated and cheaper (Telome.com), so I'm not quite willing to dismiss it entirely. I think there's something useful there, albeit relatively minor in the grand scheme.

#3 olaf.larsson

  • Guest
  • 583 posts
  • 21
  • Location:Sweden

Posted 02 December 2013 - 02:57 AM

Various bio/med-scientist have repeated the simplified telomere story for 30 years as if there was a somehow proofed that aging is caused by telomere shortening.To me telomere shortening somehow associated to aging and indicator of aging not the direct cause of aging. I will belive that aging is more directly caused by telomere length when I see a study in which animals are made to live longer by extending the telomeres of the animals.

You could as well state that gray hair and wrinkled skin is the cause of aging. "We have discovered that the cause of aging is gray hair och wrinkled skin people with those attributes have a significantly higher risk dying in the following years".

Edited by olaf.larsson, 02 December 2013 - 03:01 AM.


sponsored ad

  • Advert

#4 ggranger007

  • Guest
  • 14 posts
  • 8

Posted 11 January 2014 - 06:47 PM

I will belive that aging is more directly caused by telomere length when I see a study in which animals are made to live longer by extending the telomeres of the animals.

You have seen it and the OP linked to it. Now do you believe it? There is a reason all cancers find ways to increase telomere length to be able to divide forever.

Primary cells can only divide 50 to 70 times. Once they hit that limit - they die. If you have ever cultured primary cells and had to replace them after a few days or weeks, you are painfully aware of that fact.

Let's look at this logically. When we sustain an injury or are struck with an illness, our cell are forced to replicate. The more often this occurs, the more these cells lose telomeric length, the more likely they will accumulate mutations and will either be forced to undergo senescence or turn cancerous. Once these cells divide, the load on the remaining cells is going to increase and damage is going to exponentially occur. When you look at the person or organism as a whole, you can physically see that exponential decline as they age.

So are telomeres a cause of aging? Absolutely.

Are telomeres the only reason for aging? No, otherwise those worms or mice would have lived forever. Aubrey De Grey's ideas sound like the right methods for solving aging. Ultimately, protecting our DNA from mutations (both gDNA and mtDNA) through telomere extension and somehow protecting our mitochondrial DNA damage are the most likely keys to life extension. If cells accumulate mutations and have the wrong blueprint for generating the enzymes needed for life to function, they are going to fail. We need to find ways to prevent that. With telomere extension you allow cells to divide forever - now you just need to protect them from damage.

Edited by ggranger007, 11 January 2014 - 06:52 PM.

  • like x 1

#5 hav

  • Guest
  • 1,089 posts
  • 219
  • Location:Cape Cod, MA
  • NO

Posted 11 January 2014 - 09:10 PM

A teenager can have shorter telomeres than a 70-year-old, yet that teenager is far more likely to still be around in 20 years. The correlation between telomere length and lifespan is something that emerges when larger numbers of individuals are analyzed as a group.


"You must be joking son, where did you get those shoes?" The seventy year-old said to the teenage pilot just before he stepped out of the airplane at 10,000 feet without his parachute.

Howard




0 user(s) are reading this topic

0 members, 0 guests, 0 anonymous users