WARNING: I am going to be a complete asshole here because I have to.
FFS, this shit makes me furious. Why is it that so many people on Longecity throw around their cursory 'knowledge' of Borderline Personality Disorder like they have a single fucking clue what they are talking about or what it means? Am I being harsh? Yes, because this shit needs to be said, and posted as a sticky on the top Longecity as to not harm people with BS diagnoses.
My sister has BPD, and I grew up dealing with that shit day. It’s hell for every single person around them.
I can understand to a certain extent how you feel regarding this, as well as the intensity of the emotions - I was brought up by a step-father suffering from severe Narcissistic Personality Disorder, and I'm currently going through severe burnout caused in part by trying to maintain a relationship with a BPD-er. I know precisely what you speak of.
With that said...
You usually post some quality stuff on this forum, and I have a degree of respect for you, but your reply here was definitely not on-par. If you want me to change my mind and educate me, you should have posted with more composure.
"No, Gender Dysphoria, the feeling of your gender not matching your sex, is what causes one to be trans, not the other way around."
No, Gender Identity Disorder is the state which causes the feeling of your gender not matching your sex, the Dysphoria is, as I understand it, a secondary diagnosis, which need not necessarily develop - you don't magically get anxiety and depression right off the bat, just because you have Identity Disorder. I was a bit unclear on this though, and I understand that the acronym is the same - that's the way I perceived the information though.
I based it on the discussion going on in academia, where there is a case being made that the feeling of not fitting with your gender shouldn't be made a disease, and that it is as a matter of fact the environmental reaction to the disorder, society, which causes the anxiety and depression - the dysphoria part.
Recommendations for Revision of the DSM Diagnosis of Gender Identity Disorder in Adults
http://www.tandfonli...739.2010.509202
So much dumbfuckery and ass-backward information.
First of all, BPD isn’t classified as a ‘neuropsychiatric disease’, although if you want to be pedantic, you can classify any mental condition as such. It’s classified as a personality disorder.
Second it is NOT AT ALL similar to ADHD. ADHD is the inability to maintain sustained concentration on a specific task, with evidence coming out that this is the result of a problem in the prioritization of stimuli due to mutations on D4 receptors, and perhaps other dopamine receptors. BPD is a severe emotional disorder that causes the person to not be able to control the volume or context of their emotions correctly. The volume of their emotions are often on ‘11’. Whether happy, sad, angry, or afraid, it’s always to the max. Additionally, they have problems applying these emotions to the context of the events around them, assigning them to the wrong meaning. This gives the perception to the outsider that they can ‘snap’ at any time. This emotional chaos leads to frequent abandonment, and additionally, internal emotional chaos and rapid emotional change does not lead to a stable internal sense of self, leading to an unstable internal construction of self and identity. This is VERY different than the issues with gender identity seen with Gender Dysphoria. With gender dysphoria, the identity issue is actually clear once it’s resolved: ‘I am the gender that is opposite of the sex I am displaying’. With BPD, it’s complete instability.
For more information and research that you should have done before diagnosing someone like OP, and potentially harming him/her, check out this link in this little known website:
https://en.wikipedia...nality_disorder
I *KNOW* it's not classified as an NPD - but it *should* be!
And why are you acting all surprised that there's talks of doing so, because of emerging, NEW evidence? The same has happened with a whole ton of NPD's - ADHD and Autism used to be considered personality-disorders or trauma disorders or conduct disorders or similar, as recently as 30 years ago.
Well, those classifications were all wrong - and they caused immense unnecessary suffering because so many people were foolish enough to not look closer at the diseases before classifying them.
The same has happened to BPD - it's a disorder characterized by faulty Fronto-Amygdal circuitry - the recurring neuro-anatomical changes have been identified. And the frontal alterations ARE similar to ADHD...! It's a fact that ADHD-ers have issues with controlling emotion - that's why Borderline and ADHD sometimes get misdiagnosed as one or the other.
Here, have a look at some of the data which is emerging regarding the neuro-anatomy of the disorder:
Borderline personality disorder is a heritable brain disease
http://www.mdedge.co...order-heritable
Brain structure and function in borderline personality disorder
http://link.springer...0429-012-0379-4
Orbital frontal and amygdala volume reductions in obsessive-compulsive disorder.
https://www.ncbi.nlm...pubmed/10530633
Evidence of abnormal amygdala functioning in borderline personality disorder: a functional MRI study.
https://www.ncbi.nlm...pubmed/11522264
Amygdala-prefrontal disconnection in borderline personality disorder.
http://www.ncbi.nlm....pubmed/17203018
Neural Correlates of Disturbed Emotion Processing in Borderline Personality Disorder: A Multimodal Meta-Analysis.
http://www.ncbi.nlm....pubmed/25935068
Behavioral Inhibition System activity is associated with increased amygdala and hippocampal gray matter volume: A voxel-based morphometry study
http://www.sciencedi...05381190600797X
And yes, I *DO* also know that BPD isn't the same as GID, I know what the differences are.
I was probably unclear in my last post - I should have made it clear that I think GID is a disease (or state) independent from BPD or other comobidities - I don't think GID can, nor needs to be cured - I was simply trying to find something which the OP could get treatment for so the OP can start feeling better, and start getting control of his GID.
I must admit also that I shouldn't just have gone with what GamesGuru and others on the net said, because when I review the evidence myself, the case for PD's appearing as comorbidities among GID-ers aren't at all as clear as I thought it was - so I'm sorry about that.
Never-the-less, here's the info on comorbidities among GID-ers:
Personality Disorders in Persons with Gender Identity Disorder
https://www.hindawi....wj/2014/809058/
(the above study found Axis II - BPD among them, to be more common)
Psychiatric characteristics in transsexual individuals: multicentre study in four European countries
http://bjp.rcpsych.o...ntent/204/2/151
(the above study found that depression and anxiety was more common, but not Axis II-disorders, aka PD's like BPD)
It's actually quite hard to tell still... there's a big Iranian study which definitely shows Axis II, but Iran is a special case, where people who don't even WANT to change sex does so, because of draconian laws on sexuality - ergo, Iranian studies on this subject are sh*t.
They’re highly unstable for the reasons I mentioned above, not because of just sexual identity. Your conflation of the two is maddening.
I know why they're unstable. I know the complexity.
I was unclear in that I meant that sexual preference was a part of this instability, and that it's therefore important to know if you have both GID and BPD or if it's only one or the other.
I am 100% certain OP doesn’t have BPD. Your lack of knowledge in this area might literally be poisoning OPs mind, and adding the notion of having an extremely difficult disorder to any already extremely difficult time he is having. I am sorry I had to be such an ass, I am really am. I never have on this forum before. But there are some levels of misinformation that can be outright harmful, or even devastating, and this was really out there. I had to call you out.
You can't be a 100% certain of that - but neither am I - not certain AT ALL, in fact! That's why I want the OP to consider if the OP has some other problems as well, which could be treated and mean that the OP gets an easier time of living, so the OP can figure out the OP's Gender Identity Issues.
Now, regarding calling someone out - that can actually be a very good thing, because someone may simply be misinformed, which I admittedly partially was, or they may be malicious - a person of reason and science must then act to enlighten others, since ignorance can be a really dangerous thing.
However, there is something to be said about how one does so - I personally don't think you did a good job of it here - you're letting your emotions cloud your judgement - your message is noble, but your presentation is lacking.
Now, I think we both learned something from this, and I find you to be a sincere fellow, so I'm definitely willing to let bygones be bygones, and am willing to extend a hand where we both agree to do better in the future.
Waddaya' say? = )